STUFF HAPPENS
An Anecdotal Insight into Indian Diplomacy
Rajendra Abhyankar
Har-Anand Publications; 348 pages; Rs 895
In the preface, the author declares this book is neither an autobiography nor a memoir, but rather "a look at the practice of Indian diplomacy at a micro-level". Such studies are all too rare, which makes this work especially welcome. The book's title comes from Donald Rumsfeld, the established articulator of profundities who gave us the phrase "known unknowns, and unknown unknowns" as a guide to prognostication.
The author identifies information and access as the two essentials of diplomacy, adding to that knowledge of foreign languages, which is connected with access. The value assigned to language skills is especially welcome, as is former ambassador Rajendra Abhyankar's experience in learning languages on the fly at his varied assignments, which is what he accomplished with Italian, Arabic and Turkish - such felicity is rare. One would add to the list of professional essentials a flair for outreach, which involves people skills and, above all, personal credibility. These are the assets that lie at the core of the series of incidents and experiences that are presented in the book.
"Unusual" is the book's leitmotif, and the experiences presented in two main parts, covering Asia and Europe and West and Central Asia, are organised under that rubric in terms of encounters, situations, adventures, places and people. We have, thus, a string of episodes arranged in semi-chronological fashion. This makes for readability; by skipping over the personal narrative connectors, it also minimises the "I-me" element. Some parts of the book are a travelogue, ranging from a climb up Mount Sinai to a visit to an ancient Hindu temple in Azerbaijan, which has inscriptions in Pali, and lying on the banks of the Caspian Sea, along ancient trade routes that brought Indian traders to Central Asia. The author describes his travel to the historic city of Palmyra in Syria, whose ancient kingdom of the third century AD received an Indian emissary. We see in much of this the footprints of an oft-forgotten long reach of India.
In Baghdad in September 1980, the author had a providential escape from strafing aircraft when an Iranian aircraft raid, at the start of the Iran-Iraq war, interrupted tense open-air negotiations with striking Indian workers who were employed in one of the projects under execution by an Indian company. The author's narrative of events on July 23, 1983, when Sri Lanka erupted in ethnic violence with targeted attacks on Tamils in the capital, Colombo, is even more riveting. These episodes bring home to the reader the dangers that diplomats and their families confront at overseas posts, and why diplomatic immunity means what it does, as a vital, irreducible code of interstate behaviour. We see, indirectly, how the recent egregious outrage against the Indian deputy consul general in New York is so indefensible. We observe the propensity of Rajendra Abhyankar to be present at happening places.
Some of the episodes covered are instructive and insightful; others are vignettes that tantalise. But almost all are the stuff of real-life case studies and reveal what this profession involves - in quick response to opportunity, adaptation to circumstance and sangfroid in pursuit of core objectives. The best include: the meeting with Saddam Hussein in 2002 while accompanying the Indian minister Ram Naik, and a long citation of Hussein's views on India and world affairs (the author was the last Indian to have met the Iraq leader); the journey into Kurdish areas in 2003 and meetings with Kurdish leaders; discussions with varied religious and other leaders, including the Grand Mufti of Syria, Yasser Arafat, and Hezbollah personalities. The account of oil diplomacy in Iraq, Azerbaijan and Sudan demonstrates how different oil companies have to work with their governments in turbulent and contested environments, and how India needs to use diplomacy to access energy resources - with oil diplomacy factoring into the advancement of other interstate interests.
Indirectly, the book reveals how Indian envoys enjoy a fair amount of latitude in their actions in the confidence that their headquarters will back them. Because interstate relations cover so many different segments - whether it is local publication of books or scientific exchanges or outreach to varied regions in the assignment country - an envoy has to be alert to opportunities. Personal initiative counts for much of this. This is not the norm in all diplomatic services, and this capacity for initiative is a distinguishing mark of the best.
Mr Abhyankar is not an "Arabist" in terms of initial language training or area focus, but he took advantage of an assignment in Syria at an early stage of his career to learn the language. This served him well subsequently when he was posted to Arab countries. The ministry of external affairs needs more language and area specialists, which is an abiding lesson for all diplomatic services. The British excelled at this - until recently, when they lost focus on language studies, unlike the Americans, Chinese and Russians.
Overall, this is a fine work; it is engaging and novel in presenting a mix of a quasi-memoir and a punchy travelogue.
An Anecdotal Insight into Indian Diplomacy
Rajendra Abhyankar
Har-Anand Publications; 348 pages; Rs 895
In the preface, the author declares this book is neither an autobiography nor a memoir, but rather "a look at the practice of Indian diplomacy at a micro-level". Such studies are all too rare, which makes this work especially welcome. The book's title comes from Donald Rumsfeld, the established articulator of profundities who gave us the phrase "known unknowns, and unknown unknowns" as a guide to prognostication.
The author identifies information and access as the two essentials of diplomacy, adding to that knowledge of foreign languages, which is connected with access. The value assigned to language skills is especially welcome, as is former ambassador Rajendra Abhyankar's experience in learning languages on the fly at his varied assignments, which is what he accomplished with Italian, Arabic and Turkish - such felicity is rare. One would add to the list of professional essentials a flair for outreach, which involves people skills and, above all, personal credibility. These are the assets that lie at the core of the series of incidents and experiences that are presented in the book.
"Unusual" is the book's leitmotif, and the experiences presented in two main parts, covering Asia and Europe and West and Central Asia, are organised under that rubric in terms of encounters, situations, adventures, places and people. We have, thus, a string of episodes arranged in semi-chronological fashion. This makes for readability; by skipping over the personal narrative connectors, it also minimises the "I-me" element. Some parts of the book are a travelogue, ranging from a climb up Mount Sinai to a visit to an ancient Hindu temple in Azerbaijan, which has inscriptions in Pali, and lying on the banks of the Caspian Sea, along ancient trade routes that brought Indian traders to Central Asia. The author describes his travel to the historic city of Palmyra in Syria, whose ancient kingdom of the third century AD received an Indian emissary. We see in much of this the footprints of an oft-forgotten long reach of India.
In Baghdad in September 1980, the author had a providential escape from strafing aircraft when an Iranian aircraft raid, at the start of the Iran-Iraq war, interrupted tense open-air negotiations with striking Indian workers who were employed in one of the projects under execution by an Indian company. The author's narrative of events on July 23, 1983, when Sri Lanka erupted in ethnic violence with targeted attacks on Tamils in the capital, Colombo, is even more riveting. These episodes bring home to the reader the dangers that diplomats and their families confront at overseas posts, and why diplomatic immunity means what it does, as a vital, irreducible code of interstate behaviour. We see, indirectly, how the recent egregious outrage against the Indian deputy consul general in New York is so indefensible. We observe the propensity of Rajendra Abhyankar to be present at happening places.
Some of the episodes covered are instructive and insightful; others are vignettes that tantalise. But almost all are the stuff of real-life case studies and reveal what this profession involves - in quick response to opportunity, adaptation to circumstance and sangfroid in pursuit of core objectives. The best include: the meeting with Saddam Hussein in 2002 while accompanying the Indian minister Ram Naik, and a long citation of Hussein's views on India and world affairs (the author was the last Indian to have met the Iraq leader); the journey into Kurdish areas in 2003 and meetings with Kurdish leaders; discussions with varied religious and other leaders, including the Grand Mufti of Syria, Yasser Arafat, and Hezbollah personalities. The account of oil diplomacy in Iraq, Azerbaijan and Sudan demonstrates how different oil companies have to work with their governments in turbulent and contested environments, and how India needs to use diplomacy to access energy resources - with oil diplomacy factoring into the advancement of other interstate interests.
Indirectly, the book reveals how Indian envoys enjoy a fair amount of latitude in their actions in the confidence that their headquarters will back them. Because interstate relations cover so many different segments - whether it is local publication of books or scientific exchanges or outreach to varied regions in the assignment country - an envoy has to be alert to opportunities. Personal initiative counts for much of this. This is not the norm in all diplomatic services, and this capacity for initiative is a distinguishing mark of the best.
Mr Abhyankar is not an "Arabist" in terms of initial language training or area focus, but he took advantage of an assignment in Syria at an early stage of his career to learn the language. This served him well subsequently when he was posted to Arab countries. The ministry of external affairs needs more language and area specialists, which is an abiding lesson for all diplomatic services. The British excelled at this - until recently, when they lost focus on language studies, unlike the Americans, Chinese and Russians.
Overall, this is a fine work; it is engaging and novel in presenting a mix of a quasi-memoir and a punchy travelogue.
The reviewer is a former diplomat, author, teacher and honorary fellow, Institute of Chinese Studies, Delhi
kishanrana@gmail.com
kishanrana@gmail.com