Don’t miss the latest developments in business and finance.

Scorpio king

Image
Joshua Crasto Mumbai
Last Updated : Jun 14 2013 | 5:03 PM IST
Mahindra gives the Scorpio a makeover. What do we think of it?
 
As I sit down to write this, I have some mixed reactions. I'm just back from Mahindra's plant in Nashik, where they have launched the new Scorpio, a car that we've been looking forward to for some time now. And I'm not sure if I'm happy with the car or uneasy because it's left me wanting.
 
Don't get me wrong here, because the Scorpio is under the Suzuki Swift and the Toyota Innova on my list of favourites "" and the new Scorpio will be there too "" but it isn't taking the top spot yet. Let me tell you why.
 
The four-year-old design of the Scorpio was beginning to show. So Mahindra got to work and injected a dose of Botox into its design. Et voila, the sportier, chunkier, revamped Scorpio was born. There's much more than meets the eye (Mahindra says it incorporates 43 changes in all), but I'll tell you about what you can see first.
 
The front bumper's now got two big air-dams, which, besides keeping the splash from the tyres off the fender, works with the neat bonnet scoop, ski rack and the rear spoiler to lend the car a sporty look. The rear end has also been firmed up with taillamps that work their way to the roof. They didn't appeal to many, but I'm impressed because the car looks more sorted and complete.
 
Mahindra claims that the new Scorpio is built around customer's needs. Forty-five months of market research and a few customer outreach programmes later, they seem to be on the right track. The legroom complaints have been taken care of with middle row seats that slide.
 
They've also got new vents up front on the dash that I couldn't really figure out and angular aircon vents at the rear, so the third row isn't left out. If you're not satisfied with it, don't sweat, as you can also fit a split AC at any Mahindra dealership.
 
The centre console has been remoulded to store more coffee cups and perhaps a GPS as well, while the door panels have got more room for your maps and other bits. It's not like those additions are going to influence anybody's buying decision, but the finish, which is a notch above the previous Scorpio's, definitely will. What really caught my eye inside the car was the stereo.
 
Once, Shumi and I were discussing portable audio systems and surprisingly (we hardly ever see eye-to-eye) came to a mutual conclusion that a USB compatible music system was the solution to all our problems. Guess what? The new Scorpio's got it. I bared my 32 and thought I should definitely get myself one "" the audio system that is.
 
The new Scorpio's got its looks going for it. But don't let that bonnet scoop fool you into thinking that there is some state-of-the-art twin-turbo motor whining under the hood. You still have the 2609cc four-cylinder turbocharged common-rail engine, although a few minor changes have been made to the engine mounting points to reduce the NVH levels.
 
The CRDe engine, which was introduced last March on the old Scorpio, churns out 28.3 kgm of torque at just 1700 rpm (my favourite bit about the Scorpio) and unleashes 115 bhp at the rear wheels while returning consistent double digit fuel economy figures. Oh, and the new Scorpio is just as quick as I found out while overtaking those pesky trucks on the NH 3.
 
So far so good, the Scorpio seems to be doing fine, but this little ghat section seems to be giving it a tough time. The steering feels more connected and the car is responding to my inputs which is a big improvement from its predecessor. It's the alloy-wearing tubeless Bridgestones doing their job.
 
But the multi-link coil spring suspension at the rear which was developed in collaboration with Lotus Engineering in the UK isn't. The end result is that the Scorpio's jello-like feel around corners is still quite evident. A comprehensive test would give us an idea of whether the handling has been truly sorted "" so hold on till then.
 
The good news is that the new Scorpio rides much, much better than the earlier one, and I am sure Mahindra's customers who gave their feedback in the outreach programmes would be pretty happy with the ride quality.
 
The brakes were another area that Mahindra could have worked on, it could have inspired a bit more confidence. Hopefully now you understand why I'm not at complete ease with the new Scorpio.
 
Okay, I might be able to make amends to that because here is better news. The new Scorpio still costs as much as the old one, at least for the time being. So you can buy the fully loaded Scorpio SLX for just over Rs 9 lakh (ex-showroom Mumbai) and that's still three lakh under the top-end Tata Safari Dicor and one lakh cheaper than the top-of-the line Innova.
 
Oh, and if you do buy the Scorpio, you can use the spare cash to customise it's looks, just like the Scorpios we featured in the March issue of BSM. As for me, I'm going to have to get used to seeing the Scorpio occupy third place on my list "" for the moment.

HEAD TO HEAD

While the new Scorpio is isn't all-new there is a fair amount of work that has gone into it which makes it better equipped to face the competition. Here's what it has to fight off.

TOYOTA INNOVA
India's first proper MPV is in one word, brilliant. The Innova has ample space, is super-refined, has great interiors and for its size, is relatively easy to drive. But it is more expensive than the Scorpio and it doesn't have the off-road capability of the SUV. Nor the attitude. Yet it is one of the most well built vehicles around and is well worth the money. The Toyota badge means reliability levels are sky high as well.

Engine: 2494cc, diesel/ 1998cc petrol
Power: 102 bhp@3600 rpm/136 bhp@5600 rpm
Torque: 20.4 kgm@1400-3400 rpm/18.6 kgm@4000 rpm
Price: Rs 7.22 to 9.83 lakh/Rs 6.77 to 9.29 lakh

CHEVROLET TAVERA
The Tavera benefited hugely after Toyota pulled the plug on the Qualis and has been going great guns ever since. However, it is very conventional and doesn't have a car-like feel which the new-age MPVs do.

Interiors too aren't up to scratch nor is it the highest-quality product around. It also suffers from the people-mover image. Then again, for what it costs, the Tavera is a lot of car for your money and is extremely rugged. Fuel efficiency isn't too bad either.

Engine: 2499cc, diesel
Power: 79 bhp@3900 rpm
Torque: 19 kgm@1800 rpm
Price: Rs 6.17 to 9.10 lakh

TATA SAFARI DICOR
Tata recently gave the Safari common rail technology, a facelift and a new suffix too. So, while there is no denying that the Dicor is handsome, we aren't too impressed by the common rail job. The Safari lacks torque lower down the rev range and the new changes mean it isn't as refined as the older unit.

Having said that, it does come into its own on the highway and is a very capable mile-muncher. But it isn't put together too well. Panels gaps are huge and while the top-end version comes with a lot of equipment, finish isn't top notch.

Engine: 2956cc, diesel/ 2092cc, petrol
Power: 114 bhp@3000 rpm/135 bhp@3500 rpm
Torque: 30.4 kgm@1600-2000 rpm/19.8 kgm@ 3000 rpm
Price: Rs 7.25 to 9.64 lakh/Rs 9.35 lakh
(All prices ex-showroom, Mumbai)

 

Also Read

First Published: Mar 18 2006 | 12:00 AM IST

Next Story