 "Gold loan firms swing into action as falling prices spell trouble")
The sharp fall in gold prices could be the first sign of a deeper problem for gold loan companies and some banks.
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has capped the loan-to-value (LTV) ratio for gold loan companies at 60 per cent. But the scrap value — the actual value of jewellery (minus making charge), in 24-carat gold, if sold — is 75 per cent.
No wonder, companies have swung into action. “If the value of the underlying security has declined significantly, we are requesting customers to give additional collateral or repay part of the loan. We are following up with them through phone calls, emails and also meeting them, whenever required. If we find that a customer is not responding positively to our request, we are expediting the auction process,” said the chief financial officer of a Kerala-based firm.
He said his company could reduce the LTV for new loans by 300-400 basis points.
For banks, RBI has not prescribed any limit, but some like State Bank of India (SBI) have LTV of 70 per cent.
SBI Chairman Pratip Chaudhuri had yesterday said his bank might have to review its LTV in the event of a further fall in gold prices.
The gold price — currently at Rs 25,900 per 10 gm (24 carat) — has fallen 18 per cent over the past six months and is 21 per cent lower than the November 26 high of Rs 32,500.
Muthoot Finance MD George Alexander Muthoot said his company had factored in a 15-20 per cent fluctuation in gold prices in its business model.
But many lenders acknowledge they do not have enough margins if the downtrend continues.
According to industry estimates, 60 per cent of India’s Rs 1-lakh-crore gold loan market is controlled by the organised segment. NBFCs, which include Muthoot Finance, Manappuram Finance and Muthoot Fincorp, have a market share of 75-80 per cent. Gold loan companies charge as much as 25-30 per cent interest.
According to Muthoot, the impact of fluctuations could be minimal, since borrowers have pledged household jewellery.
“The average ticket size of our loans is Rs 40,000 and 60 per cent of our loans are below Rs 1 lakh. These factors reduce abandonment of jewellery, bringing down the possible risk due to gold price fall,” he said.
Meanwhile, Icra today downgraded ratings of Manappuram and Muthoot from stable to negative on grounds that the correction in gold prices had led to a significant increase in the proportion of higher LTV (more than 80 per cent) in Manappuram’s overall portfolio in less than a month — from around 12 per cent to 61 per cent.
Also, delays in auctioning had caused a significant build-up in delinquencies (90+ days’ delinquencies have increased from 2.44 per cent as on March 31, 2012, to 9.43 per cent as on March 20, 2013).
For Muthoot, the delinquencies rose from 3.01 per cent to 7.29 per cent during the same period.
“Going forward, delinquencies could rise further. So, any further decline in prices could add to the pressure on asset quality, the report said.
Rahul Bhasin, managing partner in Baring Private Equity Partners, which has stake in both Manappuram and Muthoot, says: “Companies will have to lend to more customers to maintain the size of their loan books and, hence, suffer some loss in operating leverage. The danger, of course, is that sometimes the hysteria might lead to repayments being stretched to cause temporary strain. But it’s not likely to matter much in the medium to long term.”
Challenging times
* RBI has prescribed 60% LTV ratio for NBFCs, none for banks
* But if auctioned, the scrap gold will fetch 10-15 % less
* Gold prices have fallen over 20 % in six months triggering margins
* Customers are being asked to part repay, provide collateral
* Delinquencies for Manappuram and Muthoot have risen sharply
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has capped the loan-to-value (LTV) ratio for gold loan companies at 60 per cent. But the scrap value — the actual value of jewellery (minus making charge), in 24-carat gold, if sold — is 75 per cent.
No wonder, companies have swung into action. “If the value of the underlying security has declined significantly, we are requesting customers to give additional collateral or repay part of the loan. We are following up with them through phone calls, emails and also meeting them, whenever required. If we find that a customer is not responding positively to our request, we are expediting the auction process,” said the chief financial officer of a Kerala-based firm.
He said his company could reduce the LTV for new loans by 300-400 basis points.
For banks, RBI has not prescribed any limit, but some like State Bank of India (SBI) have LTV of 70 per cent.
SBI Chairman Pratip Chaudhuri had yesterday said his bank might have to review its LTV in the event of a further fall in gold prices.
The gold price — currently at Rs 25,900 per 10 gm (24 carat) — has fallen 18 per cent over the past six months and is 21 per cent lower than the November 26 high of Rs 32,500.
Muthoot Finance MD George Alexander Muthoot said his company had factored in a 15-20 per cent fluctuation in gold prices in its business model.
But many lenders acknowledge they do not have enough margins if the downtrend continues.
According to industry estimates, 60 per cent of India’s Rs 1-lakh-crore gold loan market is controlled by the organised segment. NBFCs, which include Muthoot Finance, Manappuram Finance and Muthoot Fincorp, have a market share of 75-80 per cent. Gold loan companies charge as much as 25-30 per cent interest.
According to Muthoot, the impact of fluctuations could be minimal, since borrowers have pledged household jewellery.
“The average ticket size of our loans is Rs 40,000 and 60 per cent of our loans are below Rs 1 lakh. These factors reduce abandonment of jewellery, bringing down the possible risk due to gold price fall,” he said.
Meanwhile, Icra today downgraded ratings of Manappuram and Muthoot from stable to negative on grounds that the correction in gold prices had led to a significant increase in the proportion of higher LTV (more than 80 per cent) in Manappuram’s overall portfolio in less than a month — from around 12 per cent to 61 per cent.
Also, delays in auctioning had caused a significant build-up in delinquencies (90+ days’ delinquencies have increased from 2.44 per cent as on March 31, 2012, to 9.43 per cent as on March 20, 2013).
For Muthoot, the delinquencies rose from 3.01 per cent to 7.29 per cent during the same period.
“Going forward, delinquencies could rise further. So, any further decline in prices could add to the pressure on asset quality, the report said.
Rahul Bhasin, managing partner in Baring Private Equity Partners, which has stake in both Manappuram and Muthoot, says: “Companies will have to lend to more customers to maintain the size of their loan books and, hence, suffer some loss in operating leverage. The danger, of course, is that sometimes the hysteria might lead to repayments being stretched to cause temporary strain. But it’s not likely to matter much in the medium to long term.”
Challenging times
* RBI has prescribed 60% LTV ratio for NBFCs, none for banks
* But if auctioned, the scrap gold will fetch 10-15 % less
* Gold prices have fallen over 20 % in six months triggering margins
* Customers are being asked to part repay, provide collateral
* Delinquencies for Manappuram and Muthoot have risen sharply