 "Foreign funded NGO's maligning hydel projects in Uttarakhand: RLEK")
Foreign funded NGOs, with vested interest, are sparing no chance to malign the hydropower projects in Uttrakhand as the main reason behind the natural calamity that struck the energy starved state on June 16-17.
“Misled by unscientific propaganda spread by these people with vested interests, Jayanthi Natarajan, the then Minister of Environment and Forests not only stalled the hydel projects of Uttarakhand but also notified a large area, from Gaumukh to Uttarkashi, as eco-sensitive zone, resulting in stalling roads close to China border and other developmental works,” said Padamshri Avadhash Kaushal, chairperson of Rural Litigation and Entitlement Kendra (RLEK), a Dehradun-based NGO.
Kaushal alleged that Natarajan even appointed same people with non-scientific approach as members and Chairman of the high power committee to assess the reasons behind the natural calamity and also as members of a committee to monitor the eco-sensitive zone.
“The banks in the region are generally having very steep slope (almost vertical in some of the reaches). In some of the reaches the same is composed of conglomerate, which is highly susceptible to erosion. The high discharge in the rivers resulted in very high velocity causing erosion at the toe of the bank and subsequently slope failure of bank engulfing the roads/ building constructed near to the bank,” he said quoting scientific studies in this regard.
“It was due to the existence of large storage in the Tehri Dam that was helpful in absorbing a substantial amount of flow in the Bhagirathi river. The flood situation in the reach downstream of Devprayag could have been further worsened in absence of the Tehri Dam. The highest observed discharge in river Ganga at Haridwar was about 5.25 lakh cusec during the current episode. This could have been more than 6.5 lakh cusecs in the absence of the Tehri Dam,” Kaushal claimed.
One of the measures scientific committees he said, “For the losses to remain at minimum in the region, large dams should be constructed, wherever feasible, on Alaknanda/ Mandakini/ Pindar headstream of the Ganga river system. These storages could be operated in a manner to provide opportunity for absorption of flood in unfavourable condition. Possibility of storage dams on tributaries may also be explored.”
Wadia Institute of Himalayan Geology have also in their preliminary technical report on Kedarnath valley devastation given the observations that torrential rains caused vast floods in Mandakini, Saraswati, Madhu and Dudh Ganga catchments, resulting in excessive flows across all the channels. Very active erosion began due to this excess flow in all gulleys/ streams causing excessive water and sediment accumulation in the rivers. On June 17 2013 the moraine dammed Chorabari Lake was breached due to the impact of huge glacial avalanche trigged on the western slope of the lake and released large volumes of water that caused another flash flood in Kedarnath town leading to heavy devastation downstream, he said quoting the Wadia report.
The main reason for the devastation was torrential rains which activated a number of new landslides and breach of moraine, dammed Chorabari lake due to huge glacier avalanche. Thus, it becomes clear that the Hydro Electric Projects, which are being portrayed as responsible for the natural calamity are not the reason behind the natural disaster. Wadia Institute also does not mention any damage due to construction of hydroelectric projects.
“Misled by unscientific propaganda spread by these people with vested interests, Jayanthi Natarajan, the then Minister of Environment and Forests not only stalled the hydel projects of Uttarakhand but also notified a large area, from Gaumukh to Uttarkashi, as eco-sensitive zone, resulting in stalling roads close to China border and other developmental works,” said Padamshri Avadhash Kaushal, chairperson of Rural Litigation and Entitlement Kendra (RLEK), a Dehradun-based NGO.
Kaushal alleged that Natarajan even appointed same people with non-scientific approach as members and Chairman of the high power committee to assess the reasons behind the natural calamity and also as members of a committee to monitor the eco-sensitive zone.
More From This Section
Senior scientists of Central Water Commission, Ganga Flood Control Commission, India Metrological Department and Wadia Institute of Himlayan Geology have clearly attributed the calamity to high discharges in the snow-fed rivers in the region due to high melting rate of glacier during the period and unprecedented early, prolonged and heavy to very heavy rainfall in the catchment, Kaushal pointed out.
“The banks in the region are generally having very steep slope (almost vertical in some of the reaches). In some of the reaches the same is composed of conglomerate, which is highly susceptible to erosion. The high discharge in the rivers resulted in very high velocity causing erosion at the toe of the bank and subsequently slope failure of bank engulfing the roads/ building constructed near to the bank,” he said quoting scientific studies in this regard.
“It was due to the existence of large storage in the Tehri Dam that was helpful in absorbing a substantial amount of flow in the Bhagirathi river. The flood situation in the reach downstream of Devprayag could have been further worsened in absence of the Tehri Dam. The highest observed discharge in river Ganga at Haridwar was about 5.25 lakh cusec during the current episode. This could have been more than 6.5 lakh cusecs in the absence of the Tehri Dam,” Kaushal claimed.
One of the measures scientific committees he said, “For the losses to remain at minimum in the region, large dams should be constructed, wherever feasible, on Alaknanda/ Mandakini/ Pindar headstream of the Ganga river system. These storages could be operated in a manner to provide opportunity for absorption of flood in unfavourable condition. Possibility of storage dams on tributaries may also be explored.”
Wadia Institute of Himalayan Geology have also in their preliminary technical report on Kedarnath valley devastation given the observations that torrential rains caused vast floods in Mandakini, Saraswati, Madhu and Dudh Ganga catchments, resulting in excessive flows across all the channels. Very active erosion began due to this excess flow in all gulleys/ streams causing excessive water and sediment accumulation in the rivers. On June 17 2013 the moraine dammed Chorabari Lake was breached due to the impact of huge glacial avalanche trigged on the western slope of the lake and released large volumes of water that caused another flash flood in Kedarnath town leading to heavy devastation downstream, he said quoting the Wadia report.
The main reason for the devastation was torrential rains which activated a number of new landslides and breach of moraine, dammed Chorabari lake due to huge glacier avalanche. Thus, it becomes clear that the Hydro Electric Projects, which are being portrayed as responsible for the natural calamity are not the reason behind the natural disaster. Wadia Institute also does not mention any damage due to construction of hydroelectric projects.