 "Pulses traders welcome panel report")
Pulses traders have appreciated the Subramanian committee’s recommendations on measures needed for long term solutions to the commodity’s inflationary problems.
The committee headed by Chief Economic Adviser Arvind Subramanian recommended immediate increase in the minimum support price (MSP) by at least 20% for major pulses with tur and urad at Rs 60 a kg from Rs 50.50 a kg each and chana at Rs 40 a kg from the existing Rs 35 a kg.
“Wheat output stands at four times that of pulses. This means, if a farmer harvests four tonnes of wheat on a piece of land, he would get only one tonne of pulses. Therefore, MSP for pulses (tur and urad) should be four times that of wheat which currently works out to around three times. Assuming that even 10 per cent farmers are diverting there crop from wheat to pulses, India would have enough pulses,” said Pradeep Jindal, President, Pulses and Beans Importers Association.
Further, the panel recommended that the Centre should encourage states to delist pulses from Agriculture Produce Markets Committee (APMC) Act to allow farmers to sell their produce to consumers directly. The government has already adopted this practice in fruits and vegetables.
“The role of APMC is nothing beyond collecting 5.8 per cent of various taxes just to make pulses costlier,” said S P Goenka, Director, U Goenka Sons, a Mumbai-based pulses importer. “Today, farmers should be allowed to sell their produce to anyone who pay higher prices. If they feel, they can sell their output directly to consumers at the prevailing market price. The system which was set years ago as a vote bank for politicians, still continues. Today, APMC has become irrelevant. So, it should be abolished.”
Pulses traders say that this is the first time ever that the government has received right policy recommendations. Some years ago, when pulses’ export was banned, India used to be a hub for processing of varieties of dals. But when dal prices moved up, then Food Minister Sharad Pawar invoked the ban.
“The ban on pulses exports was just an eye wash. India used to import 3 million tonnes of pulses about a decade ago of which 10 per cent was processed locally for re-export which used to earn forex for India. Now, export of 10 per cent of imported goods makes no difference in its availability for domestic market as dal mills could have imported this exportable quantity extra. The ban on export not only killed our industry but also helped emerged many such processing units in the Middle East and Asian countries. It should be immediately revoked to make a market free from any hurdles,” said a senior industry official.
Similarly, traders termed as wrong the stock limit imposed by the current NDA government to control pulses inflation, and have urged the government to intensify procurement to meet its buffer requirement and purchase more in case of distress sale from farmers.
“By imposing a stock limit, the government restricted stockists to hold limited quantity which means supply is restricted. Instead of taking all corrective measures, why the government has not convened a meeting of farmers to understand the problems faced by them for growing less pulses. The increase in pulses area this year is the result of high prices during the last two years. The government, therefore, needs to take a long term measures to encourage farmers with adequate returns to their produce,” said Jindal.
Apart from urging the government to allow genetically modified seeds in pulses for higher yield, traders called for immediate ban on futures trading due to excessive speculation by certain groups of traders.
“If all these measures adopted now, India will be self-reliant in pulses in the next five years,” said Goenka.
(Source: Panel report and trade)
The committee headed by Chief Economic Adviser Arvind Subramanian recommended immediate increase in the minimum support price (MSP) by at least 20% for major pulses with tur and urad at Rs 60 a kg from Rs 50.50 a kg each and chana at Rs 40 a kg from the existing Rs 35 a kg.
“Wheat output stands at four times that of pulses. This means, if a farmer harvests four tonnes of wheat on a piece of land, he would get only one tonne of pulses. Therefore, MSP for pulses (tur and urad) should be four times that of wheat which currently works out to around three times. Assuming that even 10 per cent farmers are diverting there crop from wheat to pulses, India would have enough pulses,” said Pradeep Jindal, President, Pulses and Beans Importers Association.
More From This Section
India’s pulses consumption is estimated at around 24 million tonnes as against its production at 16.47 million tonnes in 2015-16 and 17.15 million tonnes in 2014-15 because of two years of subsequent droughts. Following a more than 30% increase in acreage on favourable monsoon, India’s pulses output is estimated to breach its previous record of 19.25 million tonnes in 2013-14 to achieve at 22 million tonnes for crop year 2016-17.
Further, the panel recommended that the Centre should encourage states to delist pulses from Agriculture Produce Markets Committee (APMC) Act to allow farmers to sell their produce to consumers directly. The government has already adopted this practice in fruits and vegetables.
“The role of APMC is nothing beyond collecting 5.8 per cent of various taxes just to make pulses costlier,” said S P Goenka, Director, U Goenka Sons, a Mumbai-based pulses importer. “Today, farmers should be allowed to sell their produce to anyone who pay higher prices. If they feel, they can sell their output directly to consumers at the prevailing market price. The system which was set years ago as a vote bank for politicians, still continues. Today, APMC has become irrelevant. So, it should be abolished.”
Pulses traders say that this is the first time ever that the government has received right policy recommendations. Some years ago, when pulses’ export was banned, India used to be a hub for processing of varieties of dals. But when dal prices moved up, then Food Minister Sharad Pawar invoked the ban.
“The ban on pulses exports was just an eye wash. India used to import 3 million tonnes of pulses about a decade ago of which 10 per cent was processed locally for re-export which used to earn forex for India. Now, export of 10 per cent of imported goods makes no difference in its availability for domestic market as dal mills could have imported this exportable quantity extra. The ban on export not only killed our industry but also helped emerged many such processing units in the Middle East and Asian countries. It should be immediately revoked to make a market free from any hurdles,” said a senior industry official.
Similarly, traders termed as wrong the stock limit imposed by the current NDA government to control pulses inflation, and have urged the government to intensify procurement to meet its buffer requirement and purchase more in case of distress sale from farmers.
“By imposing a stock limit, the government restricted stockists to hold limited quantity which means supply is restricted. Instead of taking all corrective measures, why the government has not convened a meeting of farmers to understand the problems faced by them for growing less pulses. The increase in pulses area this year is the result of high prices during the last two years. The government, therefore, needs to take a long term measures to encourage farmers with adequate returns to their produce,” said Jindal.
Apart from urging the government to allow genetically modified seeds in pulses for higher yield, traders called for immediate ban on futures trading due to excessive speculation by certain groups of traders.
“If all these measures adopted now, India will be self-reliant in pulses in the next five years,” said Goenka.
| TUNING WITH THE PANEL | |
| Major recommendations | Traders’ view |
| Raise MSP by 20% to Rs 60/kg of tur & urad; and 10% to Rs 40/kg of chana | Urgently needed, wheat output four times of tur & urad; MSP of tur & urad also requires to be four times of wheat, MSP on chana justified at Rs 40/kg |
| Delisting pulses from APMC | APMC is just a tax collection centre, delisting would help cut 5.8% levies at APMC |
| Remove export ban | Exports contributed 10% of imported pulses but added to India’s forex kitty, export an important tool for value added products |
| Withdraw stock limit | Stock limit restricted supply as importers restrained from holding higher quantity |
| Review futures trading in chana | Excessive speculation currently, a few speculators trade in groups resulting into wrong price signal |
| Encourage genetically modified seeds | Need of the hour |