Diageo is engaging in some expensive empire-building in India. An under-powered tender offer meant an earlier attempt to take control of Vijay Mallya's United Spirits was only partially successful. Now, the world's biggest spirits maker has more than doubled the price it is willing to pay, offering $1.9 billion to raise its stake to 54.8 per cent from 28.8 per cent.
At Rs 3,030 a share, the new offer equates to 38 times historic Ebitda. That's eye-popping even for a consolidated industry desperately chasing the last drops of emerging markets growth: Heineken paid 17 times trailing Ebitda for Asia Pacific Breweries in 2012, for example. At least it makes this offer more likely to succeed. A 20 per cent premium to United Spirits' share price over the last 60 days looks more reasonable - but the stock has already been lifted by bid hopes, and by optimism that an election victory for Narendra Modi will make India more business-friendly. Nor can Diageo justify the price through synergies, since there are few overlaps with its own existing operations in India.
The purchase, the first sizeable takeover by newish Chief Executive Ivan Menezes, will also take a long time to pay for itself. Diageo reckons it will take seven full years for United Spirits to make a positive contribution in "economic profit" terms, which reflects operating profit after deducting tax, exceptional charges, and the cost of capital. When it bought Turkey's Mey Icki it promised an economic profit within five years.
That's not to say the deal lacks industrial logic. Diageo's existing stake makes this less risky than an outside acquisition. United Spirits already sells an enormous 124 million cases of liquor a year. In a growing economy with a rising middle class, volumes should increase further. And, Diageo can generate more value by persuading consumers to trade up to pricier, higher-margin brands - notably its flagship Johnnie Walker range. On balance, this long-term growth opportunity was probably worth seizing. But it's not without risks. As drinks companies have found in China, already the world's largest beer market, volume doesn't always translate into healthy profit.
At Rs 3,030 a share, the new offer equates to 38 times historic Ebitda. That's eye-popping even for a consolidated industry desperately chasing the last drops of emerging markets growth: Heineken paid 17 times trailing Ebitda for Asia Pacific Breweries in 2012, for example. At least it makes this offer more likely to succeed. A 20 per cent premium to United Spirits' share price over the last 60 days looks more reasonable - but the stock has already been lifted by bid hopes, and by optimism that an election victory for Narendra Modi will make India more business-friendly. Nor can Diageo justify the price through synergies, since there are few overlaps with its own existing operations in India.
The purchase, the first sizeable takeover by newish Chief Executive Ivan Menezes, will also take a long time to pay for itself. Diageo reckons it will take seven full years for United Spirits to make a positive contribution in "economic profit" terms, which reflects operating profit after deducting tax, exceptional charges, and the cost of capital. When it bought Turkey's Mey Icki it promised an economic profit within five years.
That's not to say the deal lacks industrial logic. Diageo's existing stake makes this less risky than an outside acquisition. United Spirits already sells an enormous 124 million cases of liquor a year. In a growing economy with a rising middle class, volumes should increase further. And, Diageo can generate more value by persuading consumers to trade up to pricier, higher-margin brands - notably its flagship Johnnie Walker range. On balance, this long-term growth opportunity was probably worth seizing. But it's not without risks. As drinks companies have found in China, already the world's largest beer market, volume doesn't always translate into healthy profit.