Tony Irish, who is also on the Federation of International Cricketers' Associations, said initial voting for the post by the ten test captains had overwhelmingly chosen Australian May, who has been a long-term senior players' advocate.
However a re-vote was called and after lobbying by Indian interests, Irish claimed the voting was now 5-5 or perhaps even 6-4 in favor of India's preferred candidate Laxman Sivaramakrishnan.
"It's a sad day for the governance of cricket when players aren't allowed to freely elect their representatives," Irish told The Associated Press.
The forcing of the re-vote was indicative of the burgeoning commercial and political power of India within world cricket.
"Cricket is a global game and the decisions that are made should be global decisions for the benefit of the global game, not for the benefit of one country, whichever country that is," Irish said.