"Mohammad Issa, from UP, had submitted an application that Geeta resembles his daughter, Rubaida, who went missing 14 years ago. At that time she was 9-years-old," Indore Collector P Narhari told PTI.
But when Geeta met Issa and his wife here, she didn't recognise them, he said.
Many people have come forward claiming that Geeta was their long-lost daughter or relative but no one could establish the claim.
She was adopted by the Edhi Foundation's Bilquis Edhi and lived with her in Karachi.
Geeta returned to India on October 26, and presently she is residing at an institute run by an NGO where she will remain till her family is found.