A division Bench comprising Justice R Sudhakar and Justice S Vaidhyanathan dismissed the appeal filed by the Centre against the order of the single judge to provide Union Government's Freedom fighters (Swatantra Sainik Samman) Pension for one M Pancharathinam.
The bench said the 72-year widow of the freedom fighter had been battling for the pension since 1985. Her husband had provided Personal Knowledge Certificate (PKC) given by two reputed persons including former Tamil Nadu Minister Kakkan. He had received the state government pension.
The Judges also rejected the contention that the petitioner failed to furnish any acceptable document based primary or secondary evidence (including valid non availability of records certificate -jail record- certificate. The judges felt that the official had deliberately rejected the claim of the petitioner and made her come to court giving technical reasons.