The Delhi State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, presided by its judicial member S A Siddiqui, passed the order while allowing an appeal filed by Oriental Insurance Company Ltd against an order of a district consumer forum.
In its order of January 30, 2012, the forum had asked the insurance firm to pay the claim to Delhi resident Tilak Raj Taneja, whose vehicle was stolen on the intervening night of March 15-16, 2001.
The state commission, however, set aside the forum's order, saying, "The insurance company has direct interest in the matter...It was to indemnify the owner of the vehicle."
"Therefore, incidence of theft should have been promptly intimated to the insurance company so that the alleged theft could have been investigated promptly and efforts ought to have been made to recover the stolen vehicle," the commission said. It, however, noted that the the information to the police was given without any delay.