There are two versions about Kishor Makwana, a resident of Kob village in Junagadh district, who was captured by Pakistani maritime authorities on January 27, 2012 for allegedly "illegally" entering into their territorial waters.
One version, put out by official channels of Pakistan, India and Gujarat governments, says the 21-year-old died in Ladli jail in Karachi on February 4.
The letter, delivered on February 25, was written by Naranbhai Lakshmanbhai Chauhan, also a fisherman who hails from Chikhli village which is close to Makwana's village.
"We were waiting for Kishor's body to arrive from Pakistan, when we received the letter from Chauhan, informing us that Kishor was fine," his brother Harish Makwana told PTI.
More From This Section
Chauhan wrote that Kishor had escaped from the jail, but was recaptured after ten months. "Both of us are in Pakistan's Ladi jail," Harish said, quoting from the letter.
"In this regard, we have written to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, External Affairs Minister Salman Khurshid, Congress President Sonia Gandhi and her son Rahul, requesting them to facilitate our visit to Pakistan," Harish said.
Veljibhai Masani, Senior Vice-President of Gujarat Fishermen Association (GFA), said the Pakistani Government in its official communication has not given the cause of Kishor's death.