In separate counters to a petition by debutant director K Ravirathinam, 'Linga''s director K S Ravikumar and story writer S Ponkumaran submitted that the entire claim was based on a "flimsy thread" that the story of their film and the petitioner's story "Mullai Vanam 999" are based on Mullaiperiyar dam issue.
When nothing except official teasers and trailers had been released, how could the petitioner come to the conclusion that the story of "Linga" was the same as his story, they asked.
He had filed a sketchy report about his story on Youtube. And if one browsed the same, it would reveal that it was concerned with the Mullaiperiyar dam and how the people of six districts (in Tamil Nadu) unitedly fight for their rights over the dam located in Kerala.
It also contained a statement of some artists that the story involved a love affair between a Tamil boy and Kerala girl. Such a sketchy report does not amount to telling a story.
More From This Section
"...The story of Linga had not been published anywhere. Public, including the press, would keep guessing about the story. Though the story was by Ponkumaram, the screen play had been done by him and several other original elements had been added to it," Ravikumar said.
The statements in Youtube did not constitute publication of his story, they said.
Ravikumar said he had given many hit films, including Rajinikanth-starrer 'Padayappa' and the case had been filed to spoil his reputation. It amounted to blackmailing him, he charged.
Ponkumarman charged the petitioner was abusing the process of the court. "Though the director has taken his story, he has given a new shape to it and he himself cannot say what would be the story of Linga without watching the released version."
Claiming that the entire story was uploaded in Youtube on February 24, 2013, and it was telecast by all leading Tamil TV channels, the petitioner submitted that he decided to convert the uploaded movie into a feature film for which a 'pooja' was also held at AVM studios on February 24, 2014.
The shooting for the film was scheduled from January, 2015 and pre-shooting inspections were also conducted. The film was slated for release during the Tamil New year.