The 26-year-old actress was spotted in the nude and silver floor-sweeping outfit by Theia at the gala on February 6 in New York City and apparently cut it short after it ripped at a club after the fundraiser, reported Us magazine.
"She said that the dress had ripped -- she couldn't possibly wear it like that -- so her stylist friend went to the club bouncer and requested some scissors to repair the torn part of the dress. But what bouncer has scissors?
The dress in question is actually the same one that fellow troubled star Charlie Sheen finagled for Lohan. Sheen generously hooked up his 'Scary Movie 5' costar with the dress after personally putting in a call to celebrity stylist Phillip Bloch to outfit her for the glamorous AmFAR affair.
He even said he'd "go halfsies" with the actress to pay for the gown, an offer she did not accept. Lohan ended up borrowing the dress.