A leading environmentalist today dubbed the Lutyens' Delhi a "parasite" urban space, alleging the bungalow zone, housing the "rich" and the influential, "draws more water" and jettisons its waste outside the prime land.
In an interactive session -- 'Citification of Bharat: Emerging nightmares or exciting opportunities' at an event held here, CSE's Director General Sunita Narain also claimed that the richer the city was becoming, the "less livable" it was turning into.
Speaking in the presence of Union Urban Affairs Minister Hardeep Puri, she urged that there was a need to have a discussion on the "form of urban governance" the city required.
"I know the garbage figure and the pollution figure (for Delhi). The livability index of the city is going down. The richer the city, the less livable it is becoming, in terms of health indicators, and livability, which you would define as a quality of life in a city," she said.
Narain also claimed that the clean and green space of the Lutyens' Delhi, comparable to some of the best urban zones in the western world, has also insulated its residents from realising the "urban mess" that the city of Delhi or any other part if India is in.
"So, if one talks of Lutyens' Dehi...one part of Delhi which is complete parasite, living off on every other part of the city. It has a huge amount of land yet it doesn't deal with its waste, which goes to Okhla (landfill site). It draws more water per capita than any other part of the city," she alleged.
"And, it is so green, so clean, no one who is living here (Lutyens' Delhi) believes that Delhi or any other part of India is in the urban mess, that we are in," she said.
More From This Section
And, that is the part of the "divide that we are beginning to see", the environmentalist said.
The Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) chief also emphasised there was a need to "devolve more powers" to the local government in tackling urban issues like waste management.
She also said that while there has been an understanding of rural development in India, it has "not been so on the pattern of urban development in a country where affordable growth translates into sustainable growth".
Narain cited the example of air pollution to buttress her point, saying for sustainability, one needs to get public transport at a scale where everybody can use it.
Today only 15 per cent of people in Delhi own or drive a car yet it is congested and polluted, she said.
The CSE director general also said affordable energy is going to be "critical" in getting people the right to clean air.