Poddar won on Naqvi's first preference votes.
While Naqvi got first preference vote of 2,900, the surplus 266 (RPT 266) votes went to Poddar making his count 2,666 (RPT 2,666) and pushing JMM's Basant Soren to the third position with 2,600, election officials said.
Out of total 81 MLAs, 79 cast their votes, they said.
JMM MLA Charma Linda and Congress MLA Devendra Singh could not cast their vote.
Earlier, in the day police said JMM MLA Chamra Linda was arrested following a 2013 arrest warrant in connection with a scuffle with the guards near the assembly gates.
But another Congress MLA Nirmla Devi, who too is facing a warrant, managed to cast her vote as she was escorted by JMM working president and former chief minister Hemant Soren into the assembly.