Both Misbah and Afridi have retired from ODI cricket after Pakistan's exit from the World Cup but they will continue to play in Test and Twenty20 cricket respectively.
"Misbah-ul-Haq, Shahid Afridi and Younis Khan have given a lot of good performances for Pakistan but I am not in favor of now retaining Misbah as Test captain or Afridi as T20 captain nor considering Younis for the ODI captaincy," Mushtaq told PTI.
The former Test all-rounder said he would love to see the PCB and fans give a befitting farewell to the senior players but from a future point of view one had to move on.
"Misbah has done his best so has Afridi they have given us many moments to cherish but at some stage I think you need to step down. I don't think the decision of whether they should continue playing in any format should be left to them it is for the PCB to now take strong decisions."
Also Read
"The PCB needs to think ahead and move on with a fresh plan. Our biggest problem is finding a good captain for long term basis and some solid batsmen."
"We don't groom future captains in domestic cricket so we always face problems in this department. A captain must have the respect of his players and be willing to take strong decisions under pressure. This is why M S Dhoni is such a success."
"Some of the batsmen like Ahmed Shehzad, Umar Akmal and Sohaib Maqsood are just not willing to learn from their mistakes and grow on the mental side of cricket. It is time we find new players and start giving them exposure."
Mushtaq also picked India as favorites to defend their World Cup title.
"They appear to be the most complete team right now and I think they will beat Australia in the semi-finals but this World Cup has been a topsy turvy one.