Don’t miss the latest developments in business and finance.

SC order on CJI's power to allocate cases evokes mixed response

Image
Press Trust of India New Delhi
Last Updated : Apr 11 2018 | 9:00 PM IST

The Supreme Court's ruling that Chief Justice of India (CJI) has the "exclusive prerogative" to allocate cases and set up benches today evoked mixed response from the legal fraternity with some terming it as "correct" while other criticising the order.

A bench headed by CJI Dipak Misra today dismissed a PIL seeking evolution of a "set procedure" to constitute benches and allot cases to different benches saying the CJI was the "first among equals" and an institution in himself.

While senior advocate and former Attorney General Mukul Rohatgi said the apex court's order was correct since the CJI is the "master of the roster" and it was improper to make allegations against any of the CJIs, advocate Prashant Bhushan said that CJI Dipak Misra should not have heard the matter as his own power was being questioned.

Similarly, senior advocate Ajit Kumar Sinha said the roster and setting up of benches to hear cases has always been the CJI's prerogative, while advocate Kamini Jaiswal expressed dissapointment on the order.

Commenting on the order, Rohatgi said that roster and allocation of cases to benches in the apex court has always been done by the CJI while in the high courts, the chief justices do it.

"I think it is a correct order. The CJI is the master of the roster and it is improper to make allegations against the CJI, whether the current one or any other holder of this office, because somebody has to do the job. It is always done by the CJI in the Supreme Court and chief justices in the high court," he said.

Sinha also said that today's order was correct and law was already settled on this issue.

"This is a correct judgement. The law is already settled," he said, adding, "on roster, the prerogative is of the CJI and this has been settled by judicial pronouncements and the Supreme Court rules also. On roster and constitution of benches, CJI has the prerogative."

Disclaimer: No Business Standard Journalist was involved in creation of this content

More From This Section

First Published: Apr 11 2018 | 9:00 PM IST

Next Story