It was Mumbai which came from behind to beat Bollywood veteran Dharmendra co-owned Punjab 5-2 in the opening contest.
It was 'Best of 7 bouts' with men 65kg and women 48 kg categories being blocked.
Amidst all the chaos and confusion that marred the poorly-organised event, it was Geeta's defeat that came as the biggest surprise of the day.
The bout which saw a number of referrals being taken, ultimately ended with scores tied at 8-8. But it was of Mumbai who had the last laugh in women's 58kg category as she bagged more points on the trot as compared to her compatriot. Geeta looked out of sorts at times as her much younger opponent proved to be really good at times.
More From This Section
Earlier, in the beginning, the first bout between Vladimir Khinchegashvii (Punjab) and Rahul Aware (Mumbai) in the men's 57 kg had to be stopped after 19 seconds.
The reason for stoppage by the referee was because the cheerleaders did not know their positions and officials along with a lot of hanger-ons were just standing all around creating an atmosphere of total confusion.
The two players, who had already started their fight, went back to their respective corners and waited for the match to begin again. It was again started from scratch.
In the second bout between Mumbai's Nigerian recruit Odunaya Adekouroye and Punjab's Priyanka Phogat in women's 53 kg division, Mumbai, however, came back strongly with a 10-2 win. The Indian girl proved no match for her Nigerian opponent, going down tamely in the end.
The third bout in men's 74kg between Praveen Rana of Punjab against Pradeep of Punjab was a closely-fought affair with the scoreline reading 5-5.
But in the end, it was Praveen, who prevailed over Mumbai's Pradeep as he bagged the last two points of the fight, to again give Punjab the upper hand with a 2-1 lead.
Odikadze Elizbar of Mumbai gave his team the lead, beating India international Mausam Khatri of Punjab 8-3 in men's 97 kg.
In the first round, Elizbar gained six points to lead 6-0 and then earned two more points in the next round. Even though Khatri managed to win three point, but was it was not enough.
Once Geeta lost, Mumbai took an unassailable lead and no way could have the Punjab team made a comeback in the contest.
The final bout of the evening was played between UP's
Maria Mamashuk and Punjab's Vasilisa Marzaliuk in the 75 kg Women's category. Marzaliuk prevailed 3-1 over Mamashuk, a 2016 Olympics Silver medalist as Punjab registered a comfortable 5-2 victory over UP. With this loss, UP Dangal went out of contention in the race for the semi finals.
NCR Punjab Royals' star wrestler Odunayo, who has had two wins by the virtue of Technical Superiority, said: "The environment is very conducive. There is excitement everywhere around the world about PWL and hence I have to perform really well to make my fans happy. The turn out of fans here is amazing. I am really looking forward to my bout against Sofia Mattsson on the 16th Jan. And by God's grace same like season 1, I will go undefeated this season as well."
UP Dangal's Amit Dhankar, who exhibited some explosive action to register a win, said: "I came out on the mat with only one thought that I have to give my 100% today which I did. I was sad about my last match hence, the focus was on improving. I have previously also fought many matches with Pankaj so I knew what techniques will help me find my way today."
In UP Dangal's inaugural match against Haryana Hammers, the Uttar Pradesh franchise had chosen to block Geeta's category.
Meanwhile, Geeta's younger sister Babita, who got injured during UP Dangal's opening bout against Haryana Hammers when she was thrashed by the Rio Olympics bronze-medallist Sofia Mattsson in just 46 seconds, had been ruled out of the competition due to an injury.