UP govt hospital to pay Rs 15 L for transfusing wrong blood

The apex consumer commission has directed a government hospital in Uttar Pradesh to pay Rs 14.95 lakh to a woman for wrong blood transfusion resulting in fetal losses during her four pregnancies.
The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) also said that day by day public health is crippling due to "rampant unethical practices" in government hospitals and they should not be exonerated scot-free after such "gross negligence".
The Commission said it was a "mischievous play with the life of a pregnant woman who has to suffer throughout her lifespan".
"Day by day the public health is crippling in our country because of rampant unethical practices and negligence in the government hospitals. There is no accountability of negligence committed by the doctors working in government hospitals. The poor patients are victimised," the NCDRC bench presided by Justice J M Malik said.

The apex consumer forum asked Saharanpur-based SBD Hospital to pay Rs 14,95,000 to Neelam Gupta, who was transfused with B positive blood by the hospital after her first delivery in 1988, whereas her blood group was B negative.
"This is a very peculiar case of medical blunder a 'gross negligence' at a government hospital," the commission said, noting that due to the wrong committed by the hospital, even though Neelam became pregnant four times, till 1994, every pregnancy resulted in fetal loss.

NCDRC passed the order on an appeal filed by doctor A K Mittal against state commission's order by which he was asked to pay Rs two lakh for wrongly testing patient's blood as B positive though her blood group was B negative.

Though the apex commission held Dr Mittal "negligent" for wrong reporting of patient's blood group and asked him to pay Rs 10,000, it observed that hospital's blood bank issued blood of the same group as prescribed by the doctor and did not perform proper compatibility testing of its own.
"As per worldwide standard blood bank procedures, the blood should be issued after proper Compatibility Testing (matching of blood of patient and donor)... Therefore, we are of view that, the blood bank staff at SBD Hospital have either wrongly performed compatibility tests or negligent in their duties. Hence, the blood bank and SBD Hospital, Saharanpur are responsible in this instant case," the commission said, noting that now the patient will have no chance for second child.