Flipkart continues to be marred with valuation mark-downs, with a recent one being done by US mutual fund managed by Vanguard Investment by 25%. This is the sixth such mark down for e-commerce giant.
The mutual fund marked down the value of its shares to $102.6 as of March 2016, from $136.87 in December 2015. The company’s management cited downcycle in the internet sector as the reason for it. "Overall, these are financial cycles that happen in the whole world. I think the internet sector itself is going through a down cycle, but as the positive cycles don't last forever, the down cycles also don't last forever," said Sachin Bansal, chairman, Flipkart.
Business Standard lists out the previous five mark-downs that the company has seen in as many months.
T Rowe Price
Mutual fund management firm T Rowe Price, in April 2016, slashed its valuation in Flipkart. It fixed the per-share value from $142.26 in the December 2015 quarter to $120.69 in March 2016. Resultantly, the e-commerce firm’s valuation had dipped to $13 billion from its peak of $15.2 billion.
Also Read
“Public markets look favourably upon sustainable business models. In contrast, private markets look at impact of technologies and try to value the company based on future impact. There is a huge disconnect...the moment of truth for these companies will come when they actually go public," V Balakrishnan, founder and chairman of Exfinity Ventures, a PE fund that invests in technology firms had said.
Morgan Stanley
A minority but key investor in the e-commerce giant, Morgan Stanley marked down its valuation in Flipkart by a whopping 27% in February 2016. As per filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) by Morgan Stanley Institutional Fund Trust, it dipped the share’s value to $103.9 in December 2015 from a high of $142.2 in June 2015. "That these valuations were hyper-inflated was known and it was a matter of time before reality struck," Haresh Chawla, partner at India Value Fund, a venture capital firm had then said.
This was followed by another mark down, the second in three months, at 15.5%. With this activity, Flipkart’s total value touched down to $9.4 billion. The Morgan Stanley Institutional Fund has valued Flipkart at $87.9 per share as of March, compared with $103.97 per share in December 2015, it reported in filings to the Securities and Exchanges Commission in the US.
Valic
As of February, Valic marked down Flipkart's value by 29.4%, compared to August 2015, filings by the company with US SEc revealed. The company valued Flipkart's Series D stock at $98 a share, down from $139 a share in August.
Fidelity
A small investor in Flipkart, Fidelity Rutland Square Trust II marked down its valuation in Flipkart by 39.6% as of February, compared to last August. It valued the ecommerce giant's series D stock at $82 a share in February, down from $135.8 a share in August.