)
Sujatha Singh is the fourth instance of a foreign secretary of India to have either been asked to quit or sacked. Singh was removed six months before her two year tenure was to end. The Appointments Committee of the Cabinet, that took the decision to cut short her tenure, used the word “curtail” advisedly. For Singh, born in July 1954, was past her retirement age.
The other three instances of foreign secretaries to have been sacked or signaled to resign took place when they were yet to retire, or so claim former diplomats. Jagat Mehta in 1980, A P Venkateswaran in 1987 and S K Singh in 1990 are the three other examples of serving foreign secretaries being sacked or asked to quit before the end of their terms/reaching superannuation.
Sujatha Singh is also the third top official to be sacked by the Narendra Modi government. In the other two instances, the officials were on extended tenures.
The government removed Special Protection Group chief K Durga Prasad in end November. Prasad was on extension, his tenure having ended earlier that month. Prasad had dismissed speculation that his ouster had anything to do with Prime Minister Modi’s estranged wife Jashodaben having filed a Right to Information application about the security cover being provided to her.
In mid-January, Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar removed the chief of Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) Avinash Chander. Parrikar said the organisation needed a younger man as its head. The Appointments Committee of the Cabinet ended Chander’s contract 16 months before it was to conclude. Chander was on a two year extension given to him by the Modi government.
Three foreign secretaries who quit/ were sacked
Jagat Mehta, 1979: Mehta, one of the most respected officers to serve in the Indian Foreign Service, was sacked months before he was to retire. Prime Minister Charan Singh felt Mehta had brought in changes in India’s policies towards Pakistan, US and China that had hurt India’s interests. It was also felt that he damaged India’s standing at the Lusaka Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting, CHOGM in 1979, by promoting his own candidature for the post of the secretary general of the Commonwealth. According to former diplomat T P Sreenivasan, Mehta took the moral responsibility for the fiasco that had more to do with “inept” handling of the issue at the political level. Mehta resigned, but was asked to stay on and later dismissed when his replacement arrived.
A P Venkateswaran, 1987: Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi literally sacked Venkateswaran during his annual press conference. Venkateswaran had publicly termed the sending of the Indian Peace Keeping Force (IPKF) to Sri Lanka a mistake. When asked to respond to this by a Pakistani journalist, Gandhi famously said: Soon, you will be talking to a new foreign secretary. Venkateswaran returned to his office and resigned.
S K Singh, 1990: Singh was appointed the foreign secretary in the last months of the Rajiv Gandhi government. But life became difficult when V P Singh government took over after the Lok Sabha elections in end-1989. External Affairs Minister Inder Kumar Gujral and S K Singh hadn’t been on the best of terms when Gujral was the ambassador to Moscow in late 1970s, while S K Singh dealt with administration in Delhi. He was asked to quit months before his retirement, with Muchkund Dubey appointed the new foreign secretary.
