Business Standard

<b>Editorial:</b> Impractical controls

Image

Business Standard New Delhi

The steel ministry has obvious answers to these points. Iron ore prices were raised by a large margin last October, whereas since January steel companies have gone through several price hikes and rollbacks. So they have been able to pass on at least some of the impact of higher iron ore prices though not all as prices of other raw materials like coking coal have also risen sharply. As for the difference between domestic and foreign prices, the latter is part of long-term selling agreements under which prices are revised every year. NMDC is initiating the process of yearly review, at the end of which the vast difference between domestic and foreign selling prices should narrow considerably. If they don't disappear altogether that can be because pricing policy is laid out keeping in mind the need to develop and sustain long-term markets which do not come and go along with the boom and bust in commodity prices. Japanese and Korean buyers of iron ore undoubtedly strike a hard bargain but they are veterans at the game and set the benchmarks for global iron ore prices.

 

With Indian tariff barriers having gone down over time (currently there is no import duty on steel) it is impractical for the Indian government to try to curb domestic prices, except very temporarily, for such a widely traded commodity like steel. So differences between raw material and finished product prices will narrow once the temporary selling price freeze is over. What will not go away is the permanent unequal status between those like SAIL and Tata Steel, which have access to captive mines, and those like RINL and Essar Steel, which don't. This needs correcting by making the process of allocating mines to steel producers transparent and based on open tendering. Once this is done, the time taken to allocate mines will come down. This should happen once the new mining policy is in place. Indian steel is globally competitive and nothing should be done to take away from this through the imposition of controls and transaction costs.

Don't miss the most important news and views of the day. Get them on our Telegram channel

First Published: May 27 2008 | 12:00 AM IST

Explore News