Proposed fiscal council superfluous, pernicious

Officers, economists in FinMin have enough knowledge. There is no need to add few more of same breed

The proposal for a fiscal policy council has gained currency after the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management (FRBM) Committee recently recommended it, though not unanimously, as an autonomous body under the finance ministry. The 14th Finance Commission had also recommended the council, but the government did not implement it, and rightly so.  I am writing to say that such a council will not only be superfluous but also pernicious. The proposal has no merit.

The FRBM panel wants the council to be tasked with the monitoring of the government’s fiscal announcements for any year, providing its own forecasts and analysis,