Business Standard

Vanishing optimism

Commodity prices mirror global growth pessimism

Image

Andy Mukherjee
Commodity prices are a good indicator of global economic growth and monetary policy. Neither looks investor-friendly right now. Equity markets haven't got the message. Prices are falling for a wide variety of raw materials, from oil and cotton to corn and sugar. The S&P GSCI Enhanced Commodity Index has declined 11 percent since end-May. A strengthening dollar may have magnified the fall. But energy, metals and food have become cheaper in euros, yen and pounds, too.

The economy provides the best explanation for the simultaneous drop. Commodities tend to move in lockstep with near-term output growth, and analysts' average forecast of global GDP expansion in 2014 has fallen to 2.8 per cent, from 3.1 per cent at the start of the year. The 0.3 percentage point downgrade translates into $170 billion of lost output.
 
As long as China avoids a crash landing, commodities shouldn't collapse as they did in 2009. Then real global output shrank by $1 trillion. But commodity buyers have another reason for to be wary: a less stimulative monetary policy.

The world's most important central bank, the US Federal Reserve, is getting ready to increase rates. The Bank of England is on the same path. The Bank of Japan is hesitating to expand money-printing, despite a sharp fall in GDP. And while the European Central Bank will stimulate, it is extremely unlikely to do much.

In more ebullient times, fears about elevated geopolitical tensions would sustain commodity prices. Right now, though, the reality of insufficient demand is more powerful. The International Energy Agency last week reduced its estimate of 2014 global oil demand for the third straight month, terming the slowdown as "nothing short of remarkable." The sub-$100 barrel of oil could easily become a sub-$90 barrel.

Stock markets aren't trembling. The MSCI World index is just two per cent below its early July high. But commodity currencies could be a more accurate indicator. The exchange rates of key exporters - Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, Chile and Canada - are all falling. That suggests more price declines to come, and slower GDP growth. Shares cannot resist the demand chill forever.

Don't miss the most important news and views of the day. Get them on our Telegram channel

First Published: Sep 17 2014 | 9:32 PM IST

Explore News