Business Standard

Trump trial opens with clash over witnesses

Image

AFP Washington

ThehistoricimpeachmenttrialofUSPresidentDonaldTrumpopenedwithfireworksTuesdayasDemocratsangrilyaccusedSenateRepublicansofseekinga"cover-up"withoutwitnessesornewevidence.

WiththeUSleaderfacingpotentialremovalfromofficeforabuseofpower,hiscloseallyMitchMcConnelllaidoutgroundrulesthatwouldblocksubpoenaingkeywitnessesordocumentswhileeachsidemakesitscase--potentiallycripplingprosecutors'arguments.

Flexinghissolid53-47majority,theRepublicanSenateleaderalsomadeclearhewouldsummarilyblockanyDemocraticattemptstochangehisrules.

"Thebasicstructurewe'reproposingisjustaseminentlyfairandeven-handed,"McConnellsaid.

AdamSchiff,theleaderoftheHouseimpeachmentmanagersprosecutingTrump,counteredthattheprocess"makesnosense"foratrial,andwasdesignedinsteadtoensureevidenceisneverheardandTrumpisexculpated.

McConnell'srulesaimtomakethecase"goawayasquicklyaspossibletocoveruphismisdeeds,"SchiffsaidinhisopeningpresentationontheSenatefloor.

"It'scompletelybackwards,trialbeforeevidence,"hesaid.

"MostAmericansdon'tbelievetherewillbeafairtrial."

TrumpwasimpeachedonDecember18bytheHouseofRepresentatives,andformallychargedontheflooroftheSenatelastweekwithabuseofpowerandobstructionofCongress.

ItisonlythethirdtimeaUSpresidenthasenduredanimpeachmenttrial,afterBillClintonin1999andAndrewJohnsonin1868.

Likehistwopredecessors,TrumplooksalmostcertaintobeacquittedbytheSenateRepublicanmajorityinatrialthatcouldbeasshortastwoweeks.

Showingsomecompromise,McConnell'sinitialdraftwasmodifiedatthelastminute,allowing24hoursofargumentsbyeachsidestretchedoverthreedaysratherthanthetwo-day,12hoursadayscheduleoriginallyoutlined.

RepublicansalsoappearedreadytoremoveablockontheHousemanagerspresentingtheevidencefromtheiroriginalinvestigationtotheSenateatthebeginningofthetrial,ratherthanonlyafterargumentshavebeenmade.

ButtherewasnosuggestionthatMcConnellwouldbendonDemocratdemandsthatwitnesssubpoenasbeallowedfromtheoutset.

DemocratswanttohearfromfourcurrentandformertopTrumpaides,includingWhiteHouseChiefofStaffMickMulvaneyandformernationalsecurityadvisorJohnBolton,whohavedirectknowledgeoftheaccusationsagainstthepresident.

DuringtheHouseinvestigationTrumpclaimedexecutiveprivilegeandblockedtheirtestimony,aswellasthereleaseofdocumentssubpoenaedbytheHouse.

ThearticlesofimpeachmentstatethatTrumptriedtopressureUkraineintointerferinginthe2020electiontohelphimwin,andthentothwarttheinvestigationbyblockingwitnessesanddenyingdocumentstotheHouseofRepresentatives.

CentraltothescandalisaJuly25telephonecallinwhichTrumppushedUkrainianPresidentVolodymyrZelenskytoannounceaninvestigationofformervicepresidentJoeBiden,hispotentialopponentintheNovembervote.

TrumpisaccusedofwithholdingnearlyUSD400millioninmilitaryaidforUkraine'swaragainstRussian-backedseparatists,andrefusingZelenskyaWhiteHousemeeting,unlessheopenedaprobeofBiden.

OnSundayTrump'slegalteamissueda110-pagedefensewhichclaimedtheHousehasaccusedhimofnospecific"crime,"thattheirinvestigationwasa"riggedprocess,"andthatTrumpwaswithinhisrightstopushUkrainetoinvestigateBiden.

JaySekulow,oneofTrump'slawyers,toldtheSenateTuesdaythatthetwoarticlesofimpeachmenthaveonly"avagueallegationaboutanon-crimeallegationofabuseofpowerandobstructionofCongress."

TheimpeachmentprocessisdeeplydivisiveamongAmericans--withpollsshowingthecountrysplitdownthemiddleonwhetherthepresidentshouldberemovedfromoffice,10monthsbeforevotersgotothepollstodecidewhethertore-electhim.

ThepresidenthimselfwasinDavos,SwitzerlandfortheWorldEconomicForumonTuesday,whereherepeatedhislongstandingcharacterisationofimpeachmentasa"hoax."

InDavos,Trumpsaid,"we'remeetingwithworldleaders,themostimportantpeopleintheworldandwe'rebringingbacktremendousbusiness."

"Theother'sjustahoax,"hesaid."It'sthewitchhuntthat'sbeengoingonforyearsandfranklyit'sdisgraceful.

Disclaimer: No Business Standard Journalist was involved in creation of this content

Don't miss the most important news and views of the day. Get them on our Telegram channel

First Published: Jan 22 2020 | 2:05 AM IST

Explore News