IND-ENG 2nd Test: Sarfaraz or Rajat? Who should replace Rahul in India's XI

While Sarfaraz has the potential to unsettle English spinners with his unconventional shots in the second Test, Patidar has impressed the management with his temperament and conventional style of play

Sarfaraz Khan has been called into the Indian squad after KL Rahul was ruled out of the second Test against England, starting Friday, in Vizag. While his selection has been inevitable given his stellar record in first-class cricket, it is the question of who among him and  Rajat Ptaidar will get a chance in the India playing 11 for the second Test vs England tomorrow.

Check India vs England 2nd Test Day 1 live score and match updates here

Check India vs England 2nd Test full scorecard here

Who is a better batter among Patidar and Sarfaraz?

While Patidar has been a run-machine, scoring 4000 runs at an average of 45.97, with 12 centuries to his name in first-class cricket, Sarfaraz beats him in pure numbers as he has the fourth-best average in the history of first-class cricket, amassing 3912 runs in his kitty from 45 matches at a stunning average of 69.85.

 

Top-Five Players with Highest First-Class Averages

Player	Span	Mat	Inns	Runs	HS	Ave	100	50
DG Bradman	1927-1949	234	338	28067	452*	95.14	117	69
VM Merchant	1929-1951	150	234	13470	359*	71.64	45	52
GA Headley	1927-1954	103	164	9921	344*	69.86	33	44
SN Khan	2014-2024	45	66	3912	301*	69.85	14	11
AK Sharma	1984-2001	129	166	10120	259*	67.46	38	36

When it comes to recent form, both the batters played against the touring England Lions team. While Madhya Pradesh batter Patidar scored consecutive hundreds in the two-day practice game and the four-day first-class match, Mumbaikar Sarfaraz also scored 96 and 161 against the same opposition.

READ: Here's how Indian batters preparing for Vizag Test

Why should Sarfaraz be picked ahead of Patidar?

Sarfaraz has been an unconventional player right through his career. The first thing that made people notice him was his reverse sweeps, switch hits and paddle sweeps to pacers in the Indian Premier League (IPL) when he played for the Royal Challengers Bangalore (RCB). Although he was not very successful with that initially, he could upset the rhythm of the English spinners, which no other Indian batter seemed to have done during the Hyderabad Test.

Sarfaraz Khan First Class Stats  

Batting
FORMAT	Mat	Inns	NO	Runs	HS	Ave	BF	SR	100s	50s
FC	45	66	10	3912	301*	69.85	5550	70.48	14	11
Bowling
FORMAT	Mat	Inns	Balls	Runs	Wkts	BBI	BBM	Ave	Econ	SR
FC	45	17	412	295	5	2/32	2/48	59	4.29	82.4

Patidar, on the other hand, does not have any such strokes to his credentials. Although he was seen practising sweeps and reverse sweeps ahead of the Vizag Test, he is more of an orthodox player.

However. Patidar in a latest interview to BCCI TV said that he has been an agressive batter right through his career as well. “I have an aggressive batting style and I started playing shots at the beginning of my domestic career. It is in my habit and it's all about preparation. I have prepared myself that way, so it has become a habit now," Patidar told BCCI.TV. 

READ: Kumble feels Gill has got cushion that Pujara didn't

Patidar picked ahead of Sarfaraz

Though Patidar was picked ahead of Sarfaraz and has represented India in ODIs as well, he is more of a number three player, a slot currently given to Shubman Gill. Sarfaraz, on the other hand, has played mostly at number four and five in his First-Class career, giving one more reason why he should be picked ahead of the 30-year-old.

"I always observe his (Kohli) batting from the back of the nets, especially his footwork and body movement while batting. I try to learn and add these things into my batting," Patidar said while talking about his adimiration for the modern-day legend. 

Rajat Patidar First Class Stats

Batting
FORMAT	Mat	Inns	Runs	HS	Ave	SR	100s	50s
FC	55	93	4000	196	45.97	53.48	12	22

However, the 26-year-old Sarfaraz and Patidar can play together in the side, if the team wishes to rest Shubman Gill, who has not been in great form. Gill has not hit a fifty-plus score in his last 11 innings in Tests. In his previous 10 innings across all formats also, the Punjab batter has been unable to notch up even a half-century.